Tweak

InsaneJournal

Tweak says, "Frank is NOT insane!"

Username: 
Password:    
Remember Me
  • Create Account
  • IJ Login
  • OpenID Login
Search by : 
  • View
    • Create Account
    • IJ Login
    • OpenID Login
  • Journal
    • Post
    • Edit Entries
    • Customize Journal
    • Comment Settings
    • Recent Comments
    • Manage Tags
  • Account
    • Manage Account
    • Viewing Options
    • Manage Profile
    • Manage Notifications
    • Manage Pictures
    • Manage Schools
    • Account Status
  • Friends
    • Edit Friends
    • Edit Custom Groups
    • Friends Filter
    • Nudge Friends
    • Invite
    • Create RSS Feed
  • Asylums
    • Post
    • Asylum Invitations
    • Manage Asylums
    • Create Asylum
  • Site
    • Support
    • Upgrade Account
    • FAQs
    • Search By Location
    • Search By Interest
    • Search Randomly

randomsome1 ([info]randomsome1) wrote,
@ 2009-03-19 21:51:00

Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Current music:Tool--Wings for Marie
Entry tags:in ur novel eatin ur book, rant, work is hell

Everything I learned about what not to do in a business . . .
Okay, so I'm starting to really hate Borders Group.

Lately they've been forcing the sellers to push these two books, The Middle Place and Hotel on the Corner of Bitter and Sweet. We absolutely have to sell these books, or we all get bitched at, written up, or possibly terminated. Grouchy anonymice at Lj's iworkatborders aren't having success either--and yet Borders Group doesn't care. We've still gotta sell it.

Because nothing sells books like a frantic salesperson fearing for their job, right? Other than a used car salesman, of course.

The fact that this particular book push runs until the middle of June doesn't help things in the least bit. We get regulars in our store. Think we can push the the same book to the same people for a few months? Without driving them away? Think again.

But who really wants these books, anyway? The Middle Place is about a woman who finds out she has cancer, then finds out her dad has cancer. It's like The Last Lecture, only with a bratty narrator that I have all kinds of problems relating to. She's at the doctor's, talking about cancer treatments. The doctor tells her she has to use this hormone therapy, and one of the side effects is that she won't be able to have kids for five years. The woman starts freaking out--she wants kids, she'll be 40-something by the time she's done with it, she can't wait that long.

The doctor points out that she already has two kids.

She doesn't care. She wants more. Now.

And at this point I'm waving the book around and going, "What the fuck, woman! You've got cancer! You could die! Get some fucking priorities! Fucking adopt!"

But yeah, I'm supposed to be able to sell this to people with some modicum of effectiveness. We've tried, of course. Two coworkers have had two separate customers start crying because someone in their families has or has died of cancer. Most customers pretty much put their hands up and rapidly back off. "Cancer, huh? Thanks but no thanks." I understand--I just wish the company's higher-ups did as well.


And for the Hotel on the Corner of Bitter and Sweet--It's like if Mitch Albom wrote Snow Falling on Cedars. I liked Snow Falling on Cedars. But when you rework that with a stagnant and contradictory narrative composed of pedestrian 4th grade reading level prose--you get a decent if stereotypical feel for the one character, but there is no joy to the writing at all--then slap a cheap bendy cardboard-feeling cover on it and try to charge more than $20 a pop? Especially in this economy, and in a market where genre fiction sales are showing an increase? Let's think about how well this works.


And yet the company continues to flood their shelves with things that don't go anywhere. Dozens of large paperback horror novels from small presses with drunken editors. Dozens more Anne Brasheres, which take up a whole shelf and don't go anywhere. Stacks of manga versions of novels. Boodith. Cassie Clare does not move in our store. Her second book only sells in conjunction with the first; people who buy the first book by itself don't come back for the second. The copies of her second book that we have? They're ones we got when it came out, a year ago. I have absolutely no idea why we haven't sent them back yet.

And yet Borders' buyers, who won't give us Joe Hill, who won't keep us stocked with steady sellers like Kelley Armstrong or Jim Butcher, who won't send us any manga series but Naruto and won't fill in starter volumes and gaps in the series we already have (The fuck you mean, we can't get the first volume of Bleach?), who think it's fine to only stock unrelated segments of any number of Nora Roberts's series and no mass markets of anything Gregory Maguire, who only sent us three of Ariana Franklin's new work though we've sold ten of her first in the past two weeks, and who somehow feel no need to send us Rothfuss's Name of the Wind--even though we sell out of that faster than anything in SF/F besides Charlaine Harris--are sending us two dozen of CC's fucking third book.

You know how many of her books we've sold since December? One.

Either someone's a fucking moron or someone's trying to force this one into bestseller status. Or both.

The one similarly snarky coworker postulates that the buyers are grabbing up whatever they can get for cheap and trying to create a market rather than deal with things from the bigger publishers--whom we as a company may or may not have book credit problems with. Guiding a market is possible. Creating your own niche product/service in a market is a feasible aim. But even I know that if you nuke your employees' morale as you sink a shitton of money and hours into trying to forcibly make a market without properly thinking things through or researching your demographic first, then you've just fucked yourself.

The first step to making money? Having a product people want to buy. What we're seeing here is the equivalent of trying to force-feed plain oatmeal to a crowd in search of fruit-stuffed and whipped-cream-topped Belgian waffles. You can hope to hell they're hungry enough to eat the oatmeal, but don't expect them to not head straight out your door and to the IHOP down the street.


Business issues aside, I'm still stuck in the morass of this disaster. I can't suggest the books I know are good fun reads (since we don't have them) and can't effectively suggest the things the company is demanding I sell (because they annoy the piss out of me or because I find the original version superior). Add in the lack of raises for everyone this year, the slashed hours, and the perpetual browbeating about everything we absolutely have to be selling (beans, bunnies, these particular books) and doing (Pull stuff to send back! Tag all these things with red stickers! Tag all these other things this way! Move this! Move that! Clean this! Rearrange that!) with the constant nasty emails from Corporate (YOU'RE JUST NOT TRYING TO SELL THIS ITEM HARD ENOUGH!) and the overhanging threat to our jobs, and . . .

Yeah. It's like watching something drown, and it's towards the end, and the flailing is going into its final panicked stages and you know that if you reach in to attempt salvation, the thing's just gonna sink its teeth into your arm and drag you down with it.

Only a few months left before we find out if the company'll go on for another year. I'm not optimistic.


(Post a new comment)

Borders are screwed, that much is clear
[info]threeoranges
2009-03-20 04:57 am UTC (link)
I loved that sales pitch on the anonymous bitchfest, "If you like cancer, try THE MIDDLE PLACE!... What, you don't like cancer?"

They have to create the market for the books because they've sold themselves to the publisher, haven't they? They have to force their employees into hard-selling these mediocre-or-worse books because the other stuff - the quite obscure but fun books, the books people might actually want to read - haven't paid their premium up-front for exposure on Borders' shelves.

And they genuinely don't seem to understand that customer loyalty is at best a fragile commodity. They just don't get that if the frightened employee praises a poorly-written book to the skies and the customer buys it, that's not the end of the matter. If said customer gets the much-hyped hardback home, reads it and is hit with the realization that "Borders just conned me", s/he is hardly likely to revisit for more of the same treatment. S/he is much more likely to stick with Amazon, where the recommendations are automatically-generated, completely impersonal - and that much more likely to prove useful.

It IS like a slow-motion car wreck. Sorry you're quite this close to it.

Also, as an aside, THE MIDDLE PLACE sounds one hell of a fucked-up book. "I'm likely to die? I MUST HAVE MORE CHILDREN!!" (Great! Bring kids into the world, just to fuck them up by having them lose a parent at a traumatically early age? Splendid idea!)

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]randomsome1
2009-03-20 07:45 am UTC (link)
Did you see somewhere in that post on iworkatborders where it's noticed that a disproportionate number of reviews on amazon.com for The Middle Place are from Michigan and/or Ann Arbor--the home base for BGInc? Makes you wonder what kind of threats went down at the home office. Though with the job-slashing that's gone on there lately, their people are probably that much more overtly afraid than us at the bottom rungs.


But yeah, I have people come in from the year before that remember me because of recommendations I've made. Making a mamby-pamby rec for a book whose main character/author/narrator is one that a number of our workers have found outright unlikeable? Not good for my reputation. :P

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]yonmei
2009-03-20 07:40 am UTC (link)
Good lord.

I knew that Waterstones and all the other bookshops silently push books at customers by making the publishers pay for premium placement - and, while annoying, okay: they do that, I'm free to walk past the stacks of books into the rest of the shop and find something I actually want to read.

But one of the assets of a bookshop is enthusiastic staff who take full advantage of staff discounts to buy, who love reading, who know the stock and who genuinely can recommend books they liked to customers - and books they think the customers will like, based on what the customers are buying.

Trying to utilise that asset by making staff recommend certain books is counterproductive: destroying that asset by making staff recommend books they think are awful - that are awful, but the publisher paid the premium so what-the-hell - that's just complete bloody garbage.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]randomsome1
2009-03-20 07:50 am UTC (link)
I've seen where they've tried to make bestsellers out of things with much less heavy-handed tactics--but in two notable cases, The Expected One (lots of media hype, front cover and pages of blurb in the Borders hand-to-customers newsletter) still crashed and burned and spilled over into the bargain section, while proprietary title Slip & Fall (giant ads, gentle encouragement of sellers to note it to customers, prominent display for ever) is knocked down to bargain prices and pretty much can't be given away.

I have no idea what the company expects to pull off with this.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]wingedrivers
2009-03-20 09:26 am UTC (link)
I think you said it brilliantly enough that it's like a panicking, sinking vessel. Which is sad. I have very fond memories of Waldenbooks and to hear that this is happening with Borders is disheartening.

I'm constantly recommending people to go to Borders if they can't find the book at my store. I tell them that Borders is awesome and one of my fav places to shop. But it doens't sound like yins are having a fun time at all. *hugs tightly*

If it does go down, I hope you'll find a good job that'll treat you with respect and not force you to nab a customer and shove a book in their face because they want you to.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]randomsome1
2009-03-20 05:25 pm UTC (link)
It feels like one of those commission-only jobs where you've gotta sell something to get paid, except we have a very limited number of things we're supposed to sell and we don't get any sort of commission.


I'm still trying to figure out the Boodith thing. We don't even have staple Ramona books in. We have maybe half the Bone series with no plans of getting mid-series titles, and that's a steady-selling award-winner. We've sold out of Marr's Ink Exchange a few times, and yet we're getting less than ten of her upcoming third book. (Though for the other side of that, Marr's first book's HC version has turned up in bargain. Not a good thing for an author and a possible indication that the publisher's playing cautious with her this time.) And we still can't get or keep the Kelley Armstrong YA book in stock with anything remotely resembling punctuality or ease. Yet they want to send us ten tons of Clare. I really don't get it.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]shikomekidomi
2009-04-01 05:54 am UTC (link)
Wow, terrible times. What's really odd is one of the reasons I liked the several Borders I've been too is that even counting the comparatively small Annex (formerly a Walden Books, I think), they all had a larger manga selection than any comparable bookstores near them (in the case of the Annex the comparable bookstore was both twice their size and directly across from them and eventually forced them out, using trickery with lease agreements since the same company was renting space to both).
You'd think, however, that people would understand the idea of restocking things that sell and not adding more of things that don't no matter how out of touch they are with what the consumers really want. It's basically asking to have a store full of unbought merchandise to do otherwise.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]randomsome1
2009-04-01 06:51 am UTC (link)
So since then I learned that we're not getting a number of titles because publishers won't give Borders credit to buy them. This make-book stuff is thus Borders's attempt to get credit back, by saying "Hey, look what we did--we put this Middle Place at #2 on the paperback bestseller list." And it's working, in an immediate sense; we've got some credit again, as opposed to mid-holiday season when we couldn't get items because the company was literally out of money. But still.

(Reply to this) (Parent) (Thread)


[info]shikomekidomi
2009-04-01 07:09 am UTC (link)
So really it's one of those terrible ideas that becomes a good idea if you can get it to work just long enough to reinstate the old ways and then remember to reinstate them?

(Reply to this) (Parent) (Thread)


[info]randomsome1
2009-04-01 07:15 am UTC (link)
Yes, though the official word is that the old ways shall never come back; that we shall have these make titles until the end of Borders time.

(Reply to this) (Parent)



Home | Site Map | Manage Account | TOS | Privacy | Support | FAQs